Some anguished Patriots fans sue Roger Goodell, Robert Kraft over Deflategate loss of first-round draft pick
UPDATE: Judge sacks Pats fans in Deflategate suit.
It's a good thing today isn't April 1, because otherwise you might not believe that, yes, a group of New England Patriots fans have sued NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell for depriving the Patriots of a first-round draft pick this year over Deflategate
For good measure, their suit, filed this week in US District Court in Boston, names Patriots owner Robert Kraft, whom they charge failed to object strenuously enough to Goodell's action.
Defendant Robert Kraft had remedies to attempt to get Plaintiffs' draft pick back, but he chose his fellow billionaire owners above the Plaintiffs and fellow fans.
The suit asks a judge to order Goodell to give the Patriots back the first-round draft pick they lost, plus, of course, pay the plaintiffs damages and lawyers fees.
In their complaint, the plaintiffs describe a world of untold - at least until now - misery that Goodell has caused them and other Patriots fans in "intentional infliction of emotional distress" that violates not only the Massachusetts consumer protection law but the federal Racketeer Influenced Corrupt Organization act, normally reserved for suits involving organized crime.
Plaintiffs have dealt with embarrassment, ridicule and depression due to the rest of the country who is jealous of the Patriots "piling on" and criticizing the Patriots and their fans for being "cheaters."
Some of the fans describe their own individual levels of pain. Take, for example, Todd Orsatti, described as an adult who lives in Bristol, CT, and a Pats season-ticket holder:
Orsatti attends games with his 7 year old daughter. She will no longer go to games with him because she thinks the games are fixed by the NFL after her team was punished based merely on conjuecture. She is talking about finding another team which has left Orsatti "devastated."
Michael DiMauro, of Orlando, FL, meanwhile, reports he's suffered health problems, in particular, insomnia. He recalls the effects on him of the June meetings between "Thomas Edward Patrick Brady Jr. and Roger Stokoe Goodell" last year, in particular on June 23:
I did not fall asleep until 7am! I was awake literally all night worrying about what was going to happen at the meeting.
He adds:
My hatred has grown so much that I cannot watch ESPN or NFL Network anymore because anytime that they talk about the draft and not seeing the New England Patriots listed makes me angry and upset.
He is so upset, that he demanded a meeting with Goodell to discuss "the pain he has caused upon me." Goodell has not written back.
The suit has echoes of a 2010 attempt by a Jets fan to make the Patriots and Bill Belichick pay $185 million over tapegate. He lost.
Complete complaint (4.1M PDF).
DiMauro affidavit (1.1M PDF).
Ad:
Comments
agreed
agreed
This should be thrown out swiftly for "lack of standing"
regardless of what price these people paid for their seating. Also, the lawyer who filed this should be disbarred.
All I heard from about this case this morning
Was the lead-in on Fox 25 and it was immediately obvious the guy doesn't have standing to bring the case. And I agree with rule 11 sanctions as brought up below. The lawyer should also be sued for malpractice, because it's immediately obvious to a casual observer that he's just stealing money from these idiot Pats fans.
Dismissed for failure to
Dismissed for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.
Followed, if there is any semblance of sanity left in the legal system, by Rule 11 sanctions.
--gpm
He's been disciplined before...
http://www.courts.maine.gov/opinions_orders/supreme/bar_decisions/Bar-08...
(Not to pile on, but also: http://www.mebaroverseers.org/dah_schedule/decisions.html?id=88711
)
This is clearly someone who should not be practicing law.
Airing their grievances?
I know that they are trying to pressure the NFL, but I don't think they will pass the bar.
The suit is unlikely to gain traction
Must be nice to have the time
Must be nice to have the time and money to just sue all the time
If this works, can I sue the
If this works, can I sue the Bruins for the current distress of falling out of the playoffs?
This is downright embarrassing
Man, that's embarrassing. These are football fans?
I can imagine what fans of other NFL teams are saying now. I'm going to look at the sports sections of other newspapers around the country and see how much people are trashing NE Pats fans now.
oy gevalt
herald deflate gate plantiff
this gentleman in Rhode Island is suing for his eight year old daughter, maddy.
from the herald
Wait, wait-- you're telling
Wait, wait-- you're telling me a billionaire would rather spend time with other billionaires, instead of a bunch of yahoos on the South Shore loitering at their local Mary Lou's and listening to Howie Carr in the background? Huh. I can't imagine why.
Wait, wait-- you're telling
Wait, wait-- you're telling me a billionaire would rather spend time with other billionaires, instead of a bunch of yahoos on the South Shore loitering at their local Mary Lou's and listening to Howie Carr in the background? Huh. I can't imagine why.