Leader of Allston civic group says proposed pizza place would screw Roxbury
Allston Civic Association President Paul Berkeley found a new reason to oppose a proposed Stone Hearth Pizza at Barry's Corner: The beer and wine license it would use comes from a restaurant in an area of Roxbury the city has said doesn't have enough restaurants serving drinks with meals.
At a Boston Licensing Board hearing on Stone Hearth Pizza's proposal to buy the alcohol license from the owner of the defunct Mississippi's in Roxbury this morning, Berkeley noted that several years ago, the city convinced the state legislature to increase the number of liquor licenses in Boston to dole out permits in areas considered underserved, such as much of Roxbury (Sen. Dianne Wilkerson was recently sentenced to 3 1/2 years in federal prison for her role in obtaining the new licenses after accepting a bribe from a Roxbury businessman working for the FBI).
Because of that, Berkeley said it was hypocritical for city officials such as Mayor Tom Menino to support the proposed license transfer out of Roxbury and into "a community that feels like they've been saturated with liquor licenses." He said there's no need for beer and wine along Western Avenue because of the collapse of the local retail and housing market spurred by Harvard's takeover of large parts of the neighborhood. All Stone Hearth Pizza would do, he said, would be to draw in people from outside the area.
Berkeley has said he would oppose the restaurant even without a liquor license.
Representatives from the offices of both Mayor Menino and City Councilor Mark Ciommo reiterated their support for the proposal, saying it would help revitalize a desolate stretch of Western Avenue and said they have gotten numerous letters of support for the proposed restaurant from nearby residents.
The board actually approved a beer and wine license for the restaurant in November, under regulations relating to urban renewal districts. However, the board rescinded that license after Berkeley noticed the proposed location - a gas station bought and shut down by Harvard - is outside the urban-renewal zone created for the housing project across the street.
Restaurant lawyer Dennis Quilty said that faced with that, his client had no choice but to seek an available license to buy. The Mississippi's license "was one of the very few that was available for purchase," he said. The state limits the total number of licenses in Boston.
The licensing board votes tomorrow on whether to approve the sale of the license.
Ad:
Comments
This situation seems really
This situation seems really silly to me. Someone wants to open a new business in the Allston that was nuked by Harvard's selfishness. This will bring in a few jobs for waitstaff, cooks, etc, give tax revenue to the city, and people get someplace to eat.
What is Berkeley's problem with that?
This is really ridiculous.
This is really ridiculous. If the guy can get the funds to open a new restaurant in Lower Allston, and get a liquor license, then clearly he thinks there is plenty of demand for it. Why not let him try?
Plenty of saturation? Huh? Western Ave is a desolate wasteland when it comes to commercial activity. He even said as much. And Lower Allston is somewhat cut off from the rest of the city, sandwiched between the Mass Pike and the Charles River.
This Paul Berkeley guy is a fucking idiot. Why exactly does his "Association" exist anyhow?
Puritanism and idiocy
So basically, we want more liquor licenses to encourage restaurants in under served areas, but when those restaurants fail, the preference becomes restaurants in Roxbury or nowhere?
Then, this:
I'm sorry, but WTF'ing hell? Bringing people in from outside Lower Allston is good for Lower Allston! How can he not see that?
Get a milk crate
The only good thing to come out of this whole Stone Hearth debacle (well, besides an actual restaurant coming to LA) is that the city is finally starting to see what a complete moron Paul Berkeley and his association is. He speaks for the residents of Allston about as much as one of the crazies at Park Street. The only real difference is that he doesn't have a crate to preach from, and for some unknown reason the city actually acknowledges what he says.
The ACA needs to go. Allston could be much, much more then it is It needs someone to go out and encourage businesses to come in like Stone Hearth, not scream no to every single proposal that comes in.
Do you live in Allston?
Proposals go before the ACA and they get voted on. Stone Hearth was turned down, but only by a small margin (I forget the exact vote, but it was something like 7-6).
Any Allston resident can attend their meetings (third Weds. of the month at the Honan library); attend three of them and you get to vote. If enough people go and vote, things change. And yeah, I realize meetings can be hard to get to, let alone three in a row, but if enough people (and it wouldn't take a lot) are committed, things will change.
I'll tell you something about Allston
Like it or not, the Harvard Ave. stretch from Cambridge St. to Commonwealth Ave. looks 1000% better than it did from 1980-2005.
Really?
Why do you say that?
There have been ups and downs, but I do not see it as much better since 2005.
Some of the nastier bars are gone that were there in the early 1980's, Bunratty's, Molly's, but I do not see a huge change.
The bottle bill actually had a big impact on the appearance of the area, way less bottles and cans, and broken glass.
Oh yea.
From 1980-2000 basically every store, bar or restuarant on that stretch was the same. Over the last 5 years Id say 80% of them had some sort of renovations. For the bars you can start at O'Briens, Kinvara, Common Ground, Big City is newer, Kells is gone and renovated, Herrells is a new place....
I dunno. I drove down there yesterday and was kind of amazed as how nice it looked compared to years ago. Just seemed cleaner.
Double fail
Allston Cafe (Herrell's new name at the end) is gone, and Kinvara became the Draft almost five years ago.
Yea I know they aren't there
That was kind of my point. I'd say 80% of every single commercial property in that area had been improved/changed hands since a few years ago. They were the same dumpy places for 10-50 years before that.
Kinvara!
I'll always have a soft spot for Kinvara as the location of my first Guinness.
Meeting dates
Did a post get deleted regarding the question of 3rd/4th Wednesday? Meetings were temporarily shifted to 4th Wednesdays, and the upcoming March meeting will also be on the 4th Wednesday, March 23. After that it will be reverting to 3rd Wednesdays.
[Oops - I see that was actually in the OTHER current Allston thread, about the bank branch/former Uno's.]
Hubby & I were unable to attend last night because the meeting was in direct conflict with the public workshop meeting for the Boston Public Market, which was heavily attended and quite good. If the organizers can sustain energy through the inevitable roadblocks, the city should have a great year-round local market at long last.
(Speaking of liquor licensing, it was interesting to see that many of the small working groups at the workshop reiterated that they wanted the market to have local wines and beer as well as the expected offerings such as produce, meats, prepared foods, flowers, etc.)
You know what would be great?
If the Pizza owners said they were giving up on trying to get a liquor license, and instead was just going to leave the property as an abandoned building and let the building rot to where the assessment goes down to ziltch. But they would make sure the sidewalks were shoveled in the winter so they couldn't get fined.
They're not the property owners
Harvard is.
Oh so it would be abandoned anyway?
nt
Exactly
Harvard forced out the gas station and it's been sitting there, forlorn and boarded up, ever since.
Screwing Roxbury
Hey Berkeley, if you're so concerned about them, why don't you go live over there? Call me queer, but I don't myself usually spend much time caring about the zoning diversity of places I don't live.
A crooked man.
I don't understand, señor presidente, que paso?
I only think he is being influenced by a business an not the association he represents.
Is it a coincidence that a local pizza establishment served free food at a recent meeting?
That's up for your speculation.
Thank goodness for the reports on this and the activism of people in favor of this neighborhood.
No
Never been to an ACA meeting, but I've been to a lot of licensing-board hearings at which he's testified. He seems sincere and he's definitely consistent. Wrongheaded, perhaps, but that's no crime.
A pro(ish)-Berkeley post
Here:
Uh Huh
Working long and hard at something and doing it well are not mutually inclusive.
I don't see how he is
I don't see how he is "watching out" for us when he stands in the way of desperately needed new development.
Sounds like he is "watching out" for the narrow set of interests that he has.
Board took no action today
They voted to "defer" action, which they usually do when they need some paperwork from the applicant.