Hipsterwear: Group buys old US T-shirts overseas, resells them here, donates proceeds
Hipsters with a need for irony are flocking to a non-profit group that's figured out how to get people to buy all those T-shirts nobody wants: Wait until they're sent overseas in charity shipments, buy them back, then sell them here and use the proceeds for non-profit work.
That's the goal of Project Repat, a new Boston-based effort trying to turn old T-shirts into money for non-profit work in the developing world.
Sean Hewens and Ross Lohr, two Americans doing volunteer work in Kenya, got the idea when they started noticing plenty of T-shirts for sale there that had originally been sold in the U.S. In an interview with Universal Hub, Hewens said he was particularly entranced with a T-shirt for sale in a local market that read "I Didn't Dance My Ass Off at Josh's Bar Mitzvah." Hewens was in Kenya working for his existing Boston-based non-profit, Smallbean, which donates computer systems to remote communities on which to preserve their culture and language.
Hewens said that on a trip to neighboring Tanzania, he and Lohr discovered hundreds of similar shirts in a T-shirt market. They bought a dozen to bring back to the U.S. - and got the idea to buy up even more to re-sell back here.
"New non-profits are always struggling for funding," Hewens said, "So Ross and I thought that this idea could possibly generate revenue." Using Kickstarter as a platform to raise seed money for the idea, Project Repat took off, repatriating the underachieving t-shirts to give them a second chance back in America.
Hewens eventually found volunteers who had extra space in their suitcase to bring back more T-shirts. "So far we've sold just under 200 tees. All the shirts come with a repatriate stamp that tells the location of where they came from, when it was repatriated, and also explains the projects and proceeds, " he said. Current proceeds are going to fund scholarships for girls at a school in Tanzania - and to help fund a movie about the campaign, to be called "I Didn't Dance My Ass Off a Josh's Bar Mitzvah."
In less than a week, he said, the effort raised $5,000, enough to start filming in Africa next month and to bring back another 500 shirts. "We want to portray the depth of the used t-shirt market," he said. "So many people in the developing world have these cool hipster shirts, and if we can profile these markets and tell the story of them, we can complete the full loop and feature the whole stories of these shirts, tracking down where they came from in the U.S., and how they got to Africa and back. ... Ultimately, we want to raise enough money to keep donating to the non-profits so it can eventually sustain itself. We want to continue to raise awareness in the developing world and captivate people about this interconnected world we live in to get involved."
Hewens says he's found some pretty awesome tees, ranging from the original Bar Mitzvah shirt to a PBR tee, another favorite of his. Every repatriated shirt is $25. Hewens said he's hoping to get the project better known, starting with an open market in the South End this summer, but eventually into the retail channel that spawned some of the shirts in the first place. Along with this, Hewens has another goal, which he admits is silly. "We'd eventually like to get these repatriated shirts into stores like Urban Outfitters. They are so wonderfully authentic, there are no duplicates, and it would sort of being playing off this whole hipster movement."
Ad:
Comments
News tip
Are they really buying overseas? Not very green.
And relate this to that scam clothing donation 'charity' that has been shown to *sell* the clothes overseas rather than give to poor in Africa as implied and people expect, and then the money is used to enrich the principals of the 'non-profit' rather than go to any charitable cause. I think I saw one of their donation boxes on a university campus quite recently, despite the scandal exposed a few years ago.
Scam charity is called 'Planet Aid'
and you can read more about them here: http://TvindAlert.com . Please do not donate to their collection boxes, which unfortunately are widespread.
However, it's not fair to drag Project Repat into the mud with them.
Planet Aid
I donated a lot of eBay-able clothing over the years into a Planet Aid box, because they pretended it was to be given to poor people in Africa.
I think Planet Aid have a box at MIT, at a corridor entrance near the alumni pool. Seems like MIT administrators don't know about the scam.
Planet Aid in the news
Yes, Ron, Planet Aid is allegedly linked to a controversial organization from Denmark called "Tvind" or "Teachers Group"(TG). TG's top leaders are currently international fugitives wanted in connection with a $22 million tax fraud and embezzlement scheme.
Watch these two excellent 5-minute news investigations about Planet Aid:
http://www.myfoxdc.com/dpp/news/investigative/0512...
http://www.myfoxdc.com/dpp/news/investigative/0609...
Another national used clothes collector, "USAgain" ("use again") is also said to be tied to TG. Watch this 5 minute report on USAgain:
http://www.kirotv.com/video/21640407/index.html
Please, at least go to the
Please, at least go to the organization's website before you make comments.
How green is a repatriated shirt?
Our shirts travel back to the United States with volunteers already heading home from the developing world for any number of other reasons. If you have some extra room in your suitcase on that flight back from Nairobi, please drop us an email! And, rather than buying new t-shirts like the rest of the mass consumers in the United States, why not buy something that has already been produced?
Where does the money go?
100% of profits from the purchase of repatriated shirts support Newton-Tanzania Collaborative, Inc. (NTC) and Smallbean, Inc., two no-profit organizations that are improving lives in the developing world. Check out their websites for more information!
(Taken directly from ProjectRepat.org)
If my primary goal...
...is to get this crap out of my closets and off my bookshelves, then why exactly am I supposed to care what happens to these clothes and books once I've given them away, whether to Planet Aid or Goodwill or the library book sale or just leaving them on the sidewalk in front of my house to get scavenged?
Secondary goals
While you may care less, do you truly not care at all? It's gotta go somewhere, so why not make a choice?
I mainly want to get rid of my crap too, but I pick Goodwill over Salvation Army because I don't like their anti-gay policies.
The big question
The big question is who will take donated goods that are not actually salable? I have both clothing and books that are not good for resale - clothes are stained, torn, and worn out; books are old and falling to pieces. Neither books nor clothing can go in my weekly recycling collection. What to do?
Anyone who collects clothing.
They'll give or sell them to people who make rags out of them.
Recycling books and clothing
I read recently on the City of Boston's website that paperback books can go in the regular weekly recycling, at your house/apartment, along with everything else.
Textiles can be recycled too--I think they are shredded up into insulation. So you can get rid of your torn and stained clothing that way. I've never done it, but there are a few normal-seeming options when you google "textile recycling boston."
Can I save my T-shirts the round-trip
and donate them directly to Project Repat instead? Seems like that would be more efficient for everyone involved. (I've got piles and piles of these things that I no longer wear or want.)
Reply from Ross Lohr at Project Repat
I sent him the question above, and got this reply:
Thank you for your inquiry to Project Repat regarding donations of used clothing.
While we completely understand your request to donate domestic awesome shirts to Project Repat, and thus save the shirts the trip around the world, we (and our customers!) place a high value on the fact that our shirts are coming home from places like Tanzania and Kenya and being sold to support non-profits working in places from where the shirts are repatriated. Each shirt is unique and has a story to tell.
The fact of the matter is that no matter what we do, millions of shirts will still be shipped away to the developing world each year. We didn't create the system, nor do we necessarily approve of it. But it will always be happening, and it is the system in which Project Repat works. Our Repat agents are individuals already traveling in the developing world who are looking for a fun and socially-beneficial activity in which they can participate. Our agents bring shirts home in the extra space in their suitcases and donate them to Project Repat. Thus, our carbon impact is actually quite negligible if you consider the start of the journey to be when the shirt is found in the developing world secondhand markets.
For more information about the carbon impact of Project Repat, please see this blog post: http://www.projectrepat.org/blog/project-repat-s-c....
Also, consider the fact that the carbon impact of producing and buying a new shirt is much greater than the impact of buying a Project Repat shirt.
Thank you so much again for your inquiry. Please let me know if you have any additional questions that I can answer for you, or if you'd like to continue the discussion.
Best wishes,
Ross
God forbid third world people have "cool hipster shirts"!
Bring 'em back! To hell with global warming!
Doesn't double irony cancel
Doesn't double irony cancel out? The mind boggles.
Planet Aid is a scam?
Wow Planet Aid is a scam? This I didnt know. I know some of those "Donate Used Books" bins are a scam too, the guy resells in stores locally! (he doesnt even collect in one area, and sell in another). But then again, he doesnt claim to help anyone, except himself!
Sad to know Planet Aid was a scam.. because you're not suppose to donate to the Salvation Army if you are GBLT or GBLT Friendly, as they support anti-gay measures. Boomerangs is picky on what they will take, and suppobly Goodwill is a scam also. (a bloated "non profit"). So if you have bags of clothes you don't want.. where are ya suppose to go now?
But I digress.. this hipster thing is funny, and I agree not exactly terribly green. (think of all the energy wasted transporting these shirts from the US to another country and back again). Then selling it for a profit. I'm sorry I'm not too sure I want shirts that were in a pile of clothes in some dirty warehouse in third world country that some hipster came along and picked out to sell.
Their heart is in the right place, but sheesh, try to do something like this locally instead. I have many clothes from when I was a teenager in the 1980s still at my Dads (why I kept them I'll never know), but I know eventually they'll be 'hip' and 'cool' withe hipster crowd again. I'm happy to donate them. I was a brand whore back then.. Nike, LeTigre, Members Only, Polo, Levi's, so I have good stuff. I might even have a hypercolor shirt or a Public Image shirt in there too. Any takers?
(and please shoot me when acid washed jeans and bright orange day glow shirts are the hipster norm. I already lived thru that decade, I don't care to do it again)
what's wrong with Goodwill?
I've never heard a bad thing about them. Everyone here in Davis Square loves the store.
As for the 'Got Books' guy, if it's a choice between throwing the books away and giving them to him to sell, I'd always take the latter option. Though I might try Freecycle first. Sometimes just getting rid of stuff is more important than getting any money for it (e.g. by selling on eBay or Craigslist).
If you don't want to sell
If you don't want to sell them, try your local library first.
Got Books
Yeah, I agree. I'd rather give them to someone even if he's going to make a buck on it, than throw them away. Plus if you've ever been to one of his stores (there's one in the Square One Mall) his books are pretty reasonably priced for used books (there very few books over 5 bucks), plus he has a huge dvd and cd area with some decent titles. And he has a frequent buyers program, and Veteran and Senior discounts.
I'm not saying it justifies it, but it would be nice that its made known that its a for-profit business, not a non profit like many of people assume that these bins are for (as most of these style donation bins *are* for non-profits).
As far as Goodwill, its the typical 'bloated non-profit' stuff you hear. Overpaid people, when the $ would be better spent helping the people instead.
http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=sear...
Look at the CEO's salary.. 289k. really? How's that helping folks? Is your job that important that you NEED to be paid that much money? (She makes more than my last employer's CEO, and they were a 36Million/year company).
But then again my gripe about Goodwill is a similar gripe I have with many non-profits, as I think the idea here is non-profit, and that includes overpaying employees when the organization would benefit better from the additional funds.
But on the flipside, I DO see the work they do. They DO provide jobs and training for folks, and help people in need. Plus their retail stores are a gold mine sometimes, you can find the nicest stuff there if you look.
So its a push and pull thing for me.
Goodwill
That same page says that they spend 83.7% of their budget on Program Expenses, and only 12% on administration, 4.2% on fundraising. That compares quite favorably to a lot of other charities.
Got Books
The Got Books folks do a reasonably good job of letting you know they aren't a non-profit (it's in their FAQs) and they do mention that some of the donations at stores are tax deductible, though not the home pickup ones.
They do, however, like to tout their charitable contributions (which I'm sure have some puffery added) and it's easy to mistake them for a nonprofit. I'm always leery of "charities" that donate a "portion of the proceeds" or "profits" to some good cause as it's easy to play games with that (or simply not do it). It's also manipulative to make donors think a charity is really getting much out of the deal.
It's much more convenient to have Got Books pickup than drop off at the libraries which might have limited times/locations/dates for dropoff. I know it hurts the library sales, but there is a limit to how much I'm willing to schlep around boxes of books.
Another big scam "KARS-Cars
Another big scam "KARS-Cars for Kids" If you listen to sports radio, you know them. The use the 'for kids' money to pay for Jewish kids in NJ/NY to go to some Jewish school to 'keep their culture.' A private religious school isn't exactly what you think of when you say 'for kids.'
Just to play devil's advocate
Imagine that the money was going to teach urban poor African-American kids about self-respect, the value of education, family, and history, as well as provide early networking opportunities for succeeding in this society...
Suddenly sounds like a worthwhile charity again?
The difference is that even poor Jewish-Americans are doing fine, but African-Americans need all the charity they can get?
Kars for Kids
The issue here is that the radio commercials don't say anything at all about this being a parochial charity for kids of just one religion.
It goes further than that.
It goes further than that. It's basically one rabbi and one school.
Do a search and read about it for yourself.
No, the real issue...
...is that those are the most annoying fucking commercials known to humanity, no matter who's benefiting from them. I actually gave away a car a few years ago, but pointedly NOT to that organization just because I can't reward those godawful commercials.
I'm skeptical of this as a
I'm skeptical of this as a good business model for helping out the developing world. If this works well then wouldn't that simply drive up the price of used clothing in those markets, thus hurting the people it's supposed to be helping?
Questionable
@#26: You are absolutely right. This is a group of obviously well-meaning and creative young people, but the model is so flawed.
Giving away cheap clothes to poor markets undercuts local businesses and effectively destroys the ability of those markets to grow the necessary industries which will ensure their long-term prosperity.
Thus poverty continues and so does their need for hand-outs and unending charity.
For example, Shipping goods from Asia (where they are manufactured), to the US (where they are used for a short time), then to Africa (where they are dumped) and back again to US to be "repatriated" is a terrible business model as far as environmental concerns go. In this age of peak oil and climate uncertainty, I really do not know how we can justify this kind of thing.
All in all it is a "cute" idea, but by no means an actual solution to any problem, or as "HIGH IMPACT" as the organisation states.
******This is not a personal attack on anyone affiliated with this project, as I am sure these are all well-meaning, highly motivated people.