City council candidate plagiarizes another candidate?
By adamg on Fri, 07/29/2005 - 4:50pm
Kevin McCrea, running for an at-large seat, writes that fellow at-large candidate Sam Yoon used his exact words on housing issues at a recent ward meeting in Jamaica Plain:
... He then went on to talk about housing, and I almost fell out of my chair as he said "Now I would have supported the Neighborhood Stabilization bill but that is only a band-aid, HOUSING IS REALLY A SUPPLY AND DEMAND ISSUE AND WE NEED TO WORK ON CREATING MORE SUPPLY!" He was using my exact words that I had explained to him on Saturday!! With no credit like "Kevin McCrea explained this to me and I like his idea." ...
Topics:
Free tagging:
Ad:
Comments
Is this really plagiarism?
Reading the whole post, I see why McCrea is a little peeved at Yoon, but housing is a supply-and-demand issue and work does need to be done to increase supply. I don't think that this is such a particular and idiosyncratic way to express an idea that its repetition can be called plagiarism. Surely, McCrea was not the first to say it, nor even the first to use those words, and if Sam Yoon has done good work on housing already (as McCrea says), Yoon must already have some understanding of the low-supply, high-demand problem. If I say, "We need to put more cops on the streets to reduce crime," can I cry foul every time someone else agrees publicly?