Hey, there! Log in / Register
The dream is dead
By adamg on Fri, 04/27/2012 - 2:14pm
Workers this morning were busy bluewashing over the old murals showing the fabled One Franklin project that was supposed to rise like a phoenix from the giant hole its developers dug where Filene's used to be.
Note the red-and-white placard above the painter. It's a warning to firefighters of possible dangers inside the building.
The people who built the Ritz down Washington Street recently signed a deal with the hole's main owner to try to actually build something there.
Neighborhoods:
Topics:
Free tagging:
Ad:
Comments
Good riddance to 'One Franklin'
Not necessarily to the project, but definitely to that name. This tower, in whatever form, should proudly wear the name "Filene's" and have an address on Summer Street, which was the department store's front door.
Kinda too bad
I think that whomever took those photos had a real gift for making ordinary people look their best.
I don't know if they were actual random DTX'ers, or models, but they were a great variety of real looking people portrayed in a way such that they all looked happy and attractive.
oh and
That's the entrance to the Red and Orange lines off to the right I think. Wouldn't the fire fighters need to protect that at least?
Well
Well, chances are that's where the fire would start. Probably from trash thrown on to the Orange Line tracks.
Red X
A small point, and I don't want to start a debate, but I am curious: I thought the red sign was meant only as a warning to firefighters--that things might not be as they seem, not necessarily as a keep-out sign. Am I wrong?
This project was a political cluster-you-know-what from the beginning. Menino was scared to go against the developers who were waving money in his face so he pretty quickly put the kibosh on landmarking the Filene's building. Yet, the building was historic, and clearly significant, so there was this stop-gap approach of preserving the oldest portions of the overall structure.
I'm not trying to argue that the development wouldn't have been stalled and abandoned if the building were landmarked, nor am I trying to argue against new construction. I will argue, however that if entire building had been landmarked and protected from demolition, at least Boston wouldn't be left with a giant hole in the middle of its downtown.
Diver down?
Actually, that sign cautions emergency personnel that the building may become structurally unsound - it doesn't tell them they shouldn't bother doing anything with it. See this presentation from FEMA: http://dart.arc.nasa.gov/Recon/BUILDI~1Rev1.pdf.
Slightly different in its use
Slightly different in its use in Boston, same general idea, but the posting of buildings by BFD is more geared towards firefighting operations, whereas the FEMA document is geared towards USAR following a disaster. If a building in Boston is posted with an X, short of a known person inside, firefighters should not be in there. All of the FEMA criteria would apply, so a structurally unsound building would be posted with an X, but then other concerns can also factor in, such as buildings with holes in the floors.
If theres a fire in one of these buildings, its automatically a defensive operation, protecting the exposure buildings from the spread of fire.
This building doesn't have an
This building doesn't have an X, just the single line - it's less dangerous than an "X"ed building.
Thanks, folks
I'm now more educated than I was before. Post updated.
Wait.
I thought that sign was to signal those on the surface that there are divers below. And here all this time I've been very cautious and on the lookout for SCUBA divers when going through Downtown Crossing station.
HA!
It does remind me of a SCUB flag. I was wondering if anyone else had that thought in mind.
Give it a few years
With anticipated sea level rise, we'll all be snorkelling through the tunnels to get to work.
Slashes vs. Xs
Steve MacDonald at BFD sent me a copy of their "Posted Buildings" policy. Yes, a single slash allows for firefighters to go inside, but only with "extreme caution," while an X basically means stay out, unless "a life hazard exists."
However, he adds:
Too late now
But while that hole sat there stupid for so long, wouldn't it have been kind of a cool spot for an archaelogical dig? That part of Shawmut, and then Boston, has been inhabited for thousands of years. Gotta wonder what they would have found,
Not much
You can't dig too far down there before hitting bedrock and/or water. Any cool artifacts would have been excavated just to build the hole in the first place.
It's been there so long
I'm surprised the Hole doesn't have "historical site" protections.
Viva the Hole!
Viva the Hole!