Red Line train dies, every rider sighs; commuter rail still a travail
By adamg on Wed, 02/25/2015 - 8:36am
Molly Lanzarotta was among those crammed into South Station on the Red Line around 8:15 a.m., where a train tried but failed to come to grips with its own mortality.
Meanwhile, on commuter rail, let's see: Keolis said the advisories that entire lines were simply canceled every Wednesday, Thursday and Friday were a technical glitch, not a hack. Many trains remained actually canceled. The trains that did show up were overpacked, leaving passengers behind on platforms. Many were delayed due to a late turn of equipment. One Needham Line train slid by a station altogether and had to back up.
Topics:
Free tagging:
Ad:
Comments
The latest issue I have with the MBTA
regarding commuter rail is that they are no longer posting alerts on the message boards at the stations. This morning, they allegedly ran an extra train that left Reading at 7:45 am. While they did send out an alert about it, the conductor on the 7:30 train (which was the same overpacked sardine can It's been for the past week) claimed to know nothing about it.
And a memo to the MBTA: Not everyone has smartphones, and most of us who do don't have them surgically grafted to their hands. Likewise, most of us with phones don't want to remove our gloves to check for a new alert every two minutes when it's frigid cold outside.
They sell
Smartphone gloves that have one metal-fiber fingertip so you can use your phone without taking off your gloves.
That said, most also don't have rubber grips on the palm, so the likelihood of dropping your phone while using them is pretty high.
So your advice is that
everyone who has a smartphone and relies on T alerts should go out and buy a special pair of gloves which, by your own admission, may not even work well in terms of using the phone. Instead, what's so wrong with requiring that the T provide passenger information using the equipment (message signs) that is already installed at the stations.
For the record, I own a pair of those "smartphone friendly" gloves. Used them once, and discovered they are not the best for using the phone. More importantly, they don't insulate my hands on an average chilly day nearly as well as my older cloth ones do.
Breathe, roadman, breathe
The previous poster wasn't telling you to buy a pair of touchscreen gloves and suck it up, buttercup. She/he was simply offering a partial solution to your problem, with a considerable caveat. No shooting of messengers, ok?
The Commuter Rail is just ballsed forever.
I usually take a train that hits Mansfield at 7:26 and starts empty. That train is one of the casualties of the "recovery schedule", so for the last week and a half I've taken the one that comes at 5:55 instead. It's tiring, but that way at least I know I won't get stuck on a standing-room-only train and be susceptible to a panic attack, which happened to me a couple of weeks ago when they sent a short train with all single cars at the height of rush hour.
I'm really sick of it and I wish they'd stop with the alleged "recovery" and get back to normal frigging business already. Everyone's all "the MBTA's back to normal!" but the commuter rail is still very much not.
FWIW, the T says a train has
FWIW, the T says a train has originated in Mansfield each of the last two mornings (7:26 yesterday and, oddly, 7:44 today, according to the alerts I saw). As mentioned elsewhere, word of those "additions" to the "recovery" schedule comes via Twitter and the alert system (email or text), so you have to be on the lookout for them. It's very confusing.
WELP
That's completely stupid and rude (announcing the extras only via twitter/alerts, I mean)! But in the end, I don't trust that what they say they'll add the night before will actually happen, and I don't want to get stuck on a sardine train, so I'd still err on the side of caution and take the earliest train possible.
Their Twitter alerts are
Their Twitter alerts are sketchy at best.
Most of their text alerts
lately have been sketchy at best. Consider these examples I've recently received:
An empty train making the
An empty train making the usual 7:26 from Mansfield stops did indeed arrive right after the 7:44 train left Mansfield today (you could see the lights right after the 7:44 rolled out, passengers inside packed like sardines). By the time we left Canton Junction we were just as full as the 7:44 was after Mansfield, but at least we could let people on (unlike on Monday). Hopefully they keep running this extra, at 7:26 or 7:44ish. Makes things (slightly) less hellish.
I saw the tweet announcing the extra 7:44 today
But since there was already the usual 7:44, I was concerned it was a typo or wouldn't happen. Glad to see they're adding service, since they obviously NEED to if it was that full by CJ. Sigh. I'm still gonna stick with the CJ rather than risk it. Thanks!
A La Douglas Adams, Broken Train Goddess Here
Yesterday, I decided to try to take the one commuter train on the Greenbush line that arrives in Boston at a humane hour. First alert, delayed 10 to 15, second alert delayed 20 to 30, third alert delayed 35 to 45. It was -1 degrees and we yelled warnings to fellow commuters walking to the train to make sure they would not stand and wait in this cold. The train showed up packed to the gills, half with BC High students. No one got off at JFK/UMass to let the kids out. Why yes, let me lean into a complete stranger and pretend I am suddenly two dimensional as you drag your backpack across my torso.
Today, I opted for the red line. Delayed first due to a medical emergency at Downtown Crossing and the next delay due to the aforementioned dead train at South Station. It was so bad, a Braintree train kicked everyone off and reversed direction into Boston to pick up us poor stranded bastards at North Quincy.
If I drive tomorrow, please expect Furnace Brook Parkway to collapse or burst into flames.
GAH.
Well, we can be broken train goddesses together. Since I started working in Cambridge last February, delays increased exponentially (or so reports my partner, who started working in Cambridge three months before that and experienced no such delays).
Whatta think Roadman?
Do you think they are using this today to determine alerts?
(I saw this on Twitter yesterday and IMMEDIATELY thought of you!)
So, the
legendary Patented Pestuaro Prediction System (with apologies to Jay Ward) really does exist after all.
fantastic!
n/t
Canoeing the Keolis Stream of Consciousness
541a: Fairmount Line delayed until further notice every Wed, Thurs, Fri [you mean, a normal schedule, right?]
600a: Good Morning [I kid you not], AM Commute Forecast: The current snow conditions should not affect the morning's commute [yay! but will believe when I see it]
630a: Please disregard previous T-Alert regarding delays [which one?]
645a:Please disregard previous T-Alert regarding delays [shit, now which one??]
700a: Fairmount Line Good Morning [I kid you not], AM Commute Forecast: The current snow conditions should not affect the morning's commute [is there an echo on this platform??]
715a: Fairmount Line Train 746 currently delayed 10 to 15 minutes due to earlier late equipment [what could this possibly mean?]
Train 746 pulled in 12 minutes late...everyone comparatively happy.
Go home Keolis...
...yer drunk.
and French.
Dear Governor Baker,
We hope that you enjoyed the weekend in D.C., said hello to Chris C. the bombastic Jersey Boy for us, and enjoyed some time with your son.
We'd like to draw your attention to your "the thing had better work" comment from last week regarding the commuter rail.
I don't know which cockamamie definition someone is using for "work", but this sure as hell isn't working for very many people.
Sincerely,
Your Suburban Power Base
That trip to DC
You mean the one where he met with our Congressional delegation and the President asking for storm relief money?
I'm not saying he should ignore the continuing commuter rail meltdown, just that it's not like he was jetting off on a weekend vacation.
Sorry, Waquiot, my tone was a bit off there.
I didn't mean to suggest that he was on a vacation. I have absolutely no problem with the Governor's trip to D.C for the Governor's meeting or even if he had gone just to see his child. (I would note, however, that anything involving requests for storm relief money were add-ons to the trip, and certainly do not have to be made in person). I wouldn't even care in the abstract if he had spent the whole time running around with the RGA people and their K St. allies (he didn't) - he's a Republican, he's a Governor and that's politics.
What I was trying to point out was that the work that he demanded be undertaken in his absence on the commuter rail does not seem to have been accomplished, and I have heard no acknowledgement of that from him, Keolis or the T.
Hell, I don't ride the commuter rail, nor do I live in the commuter rail suburbs, but I though it interesting that the part of the transport system that serves the people who are generally considered to comprise his power base is the part of the system that is still in the worst shape.
And I agree with you
Although, getting things online "right away" might be a tall order, he should be still holding Kerolis' feet to the fire. Like I was saying with the subway- give us a timeline and set out why this is happening and at least we can have an idea of when things will get back to normal.
The bully pulpit is one of the greatest things a governor (or mayor or even President) has. Heck, he kind of scared Beverly Scott away after throwing her under the bus (not that I agreed with him on that) at a press conference, but he was just saying what a lot of us were thinking about the T.
(edited for a name screw up.)
Who is Carol Scott?
Who is Carol Scott?
Beverly Scott's Alter Ego
She fights crime and performs surgery under that name.
I will edit, and I will feel shame. I do know a Carol Scott, but her association with the T is the same as the rest of us.
Baker's mistake...
...making a heavy-handed threat-sounding statement about something that "better" happen, without any means or intention of enforcing consequences if it didn't. I'm not surprised he got elected, but with rookie mistakes like this, I will be surprised if he wins another one.
Anyone else find it kind of
Anyone else find it kind of ballsy to ask the feds for a bailout while at the same time taking increased state tax revenue off the table?
I know from watching The Wire
I know from watching The Wire that it doesn't bode well if Baker wants a political job at the national level one day.
That said, whether it's a bailout or not, I don't have a problem with him asking for federal dollars, if it's going to the right things, and if it will prevent state programs from being cut to fund disaster relief. I don't know how many other times this state has asked for money from the feds but I can bet we've done so a lot less than other states.
I know Gov Baker said he
I know Gov Baker said he wouldn't make any symbolic trips on the commuter rail, but I hope that one day he decides to take the 4:20 or 5:40 train home to Swampscott (since there are no other trains on the Newburyport line between those times on the recovery schedule) and gets to see the evening mess at North Station firsthand.
Do you expect him to stand
Do you expect him to stand over the Keolis' operator's shoulder and make sure the trains are leaving the stations at the exact time noted?
I'm not sure what else you expect him to do personally on weekends besides telling other people to do their jobs. He can't work the switches himself. He's not a conductor or an engineer. I'm not a Baker fan myself but to play devil's advocate here, he's got to extend professional courtesy to the people with this expertise and experience of running the trains and give them time to figure this out without micromanaging the situation. There are also other issues he's got on his plate besides the transportation debacle on a day to day basis that probably need his attention.
And if he wants to work in a lunch with his kid while in the midst of his gubernatorial duties in DC, why should we care? As an elected official he's pretty much on the clock at all times, so if he's able to schedule in personal time on a weekend with his kid, why should we complain about that?
"tried but failed to come to grips w its own mortality"
Lol'd on my jam-packed red line train. Enjoyed even more than "pinning for the fjords," which had been my fave up til now.
DO SOMETHING, BAKER!
We can't get to work! How do our kids eat?
My commute, this week, has
been good.
My train in to Boston has been on time (Readville Line) but is slow traveling to the city, arriving at South Station 15-20 minutes late.
My train home (Franklin) has been boarding on time since Monday.
Red Line has been good, this week, except today. The entire staff of one of our departments are currently stuck all along the line and have yet to arrive to work.
I wonder when Keolis will be giving their "robust recovery plan" to Gov. Baker. I do hope if he does not receive it soon, he puts on his proactive hat and gives them a ringy dingy (sooner than he called Dr. Scott) for a status update.
Where are the complaints from business?
Maybe I'm missing something, but I'm surprised businesses haven't been complaining more. The economic loss of shutting/slowing down because employees/customers can't get to the business has been staggering. All businesses, big and small, are impacted, and when businesses are impacted, it filters down to the employees.
They might indeed be complaining...
When I called the Govs office, last week, and spoke with his aide, she informed me that she had logged many, many complaints. Some (or many) of them just might be from businesses.
I know my boss has
He was a high ranking official in the Weld administration, and he uses public transit.
Good question
Presumably there are some behind the scenes conversations going on with the Chamber, Mass Competitive Partnership and whatnot, but really they probably don't want to stand up and draw attention to the fact that they rely so heavily on public transit because then people might ask them to pay into it more. God knows they will be telling the riders to fork over more change if the "reform before revenue" mantra continues, because fares are one thing, taxes are another.
The Mayor of Somerville has
The Mayor of Somerville has raised the issue.
It makes for an interesting case in which both parties might be united. The business community needs investment in public transit in order for their businesses to run smoothly and efficiently, in all aspects - for their current and prospective employees, customer foot traffic, etc.
Too busy?
A lot of them are probably too busy just coping as best they can. The complaints will come, believe it, but the day-to-day is taking precedence now.
CLF and MassPirg Complaining not enough unsustainable expansion!
The failure of the overextended MBTA hasn't satisfied the litigation happy Conservation Law Foundation. They (and Arlington Rep. Sean Garballey) want yet more failures and debt! This is like a gambler trying to gamble himself out of debt, only to get deeper in it.
http://www.bostonherald.com/news_opinion/local_politics/2015/02/pols_gro...
Here's a Tip
Instead of complaining that MA got caught ignoring a federal contract provision, why don't you call up Bechtel and ask them for all the money that they overspent on the Big Dig instead?
ORRRRR
He could just shove it.
The second one!!
The second one!! Oooh! Ooh! The second one!! The second one!!
CLF
That Herald article makes it sound like CLF and friends have been advocating that the MBTA expand and NOT spend on maintenance. In fact they've been advocates for increased maintenance spending AND expansion - with the idea that if the system doesn't go out to where it is needed ridership will not go up, and along with that revenue. Whether doing both is possible, well there's a question there. The MTA gets people to where they need to go, when they need to go and parking in NYC is frequently not an (affordable) option, therefore huge ridership and revenue - it would be nice to see that here.
If people want to slam expansion like the Greenbush line go ahead. I'd gladly take that half a billion dollars and invest it in new switches and signaling equipment. The failure to do that is a valid criticism. The failure to maintain or buy new snow removal equipment - another valid one. Looking under the hood at salaries and pension benefits - a good exercise as it is unclear as to whether there are very real, valid criticisms there or if this is another case of people expecting public services just to run perfectly for free. Complaining about not enough highway capacity, or that bikes are to blame or that the Green Line returning to one of the densest populated cities in the country is an unneeded expansion - stupidity.
CLF keeps hitting our pockets
The differences between Bechtel and CLF is that Bechtel actually builds things while CLF just creates costs over and over again. Bechtel got paid and is done. CLF is looking for new ways to cost Mass residents with new debt for the MBTA and ever higher electricity prices (by demanding natural gas powered plants lower carbon dioxide (what we exhale) emissions. Both groups are happy about the natural gas pipeline shortage in Massachusetts which jacks up winter heating and electric costs to residents. I suppose they want people to sit in the cold and dark to offset China's increasing carbon footprint.
Do not donate a penny to MassPIRG or Conservation Law Foundation!
I'm going to give $10 every
I'm going to give $10 every time you advocate otherwise, to offset ANY effects you might have on their donations.
Here's another tip.........
Here's another tip......... the federal contract provision you are referring to didn't materialize out of nothing. It was lobbied for by the CLF under threat that if the expansion of the T wasn't included as part of the Big Dig then the CLF would sue to block the Big Dig. And thus we have hundreds of millions of dollars going into new the Greenbush Line ( including about $200 million to tunnel under Hingham Center) rather than going into an old system that obviously needed money for maintenance.
Most voters would support additional taxes to resolve the T's problems; but not to expand the T. Of course if transit policy doesn't go the CLF's way they'll be back in court.
So it is the voters vs. the CLF. The CLF can cower the Legislature but the voters not so easily.
By all means
Explain your familiarity with federal contracts and the requirements of highway project contracts at the time of the big dig.
Transit projects were required by Congress for large omnibus road building contracts.
Waiting ...
Some expansion
One new subway station since 1987, and the only actual expansion of the core system is another slow trolley line.
Yes
That's exactly what the T needs, more debt through more expansion in the most expensive place in the region to build.
Any thoughts as to where these new stations should go, and how much more in debt the T will go into to build them?
Conversely, are you going to say to the people on the Plymouth and Middleboro lines, along with the people out in Metro West/Worcester that the T has done nothing to make their commutes better, this recent SNFU aside?
No context - what does 1 station mean?
How many new stations has Philly, Chicago, or NYC added in the same time period? What percentage of their system does the expansion represent? NYC has a much larger system than the MBTA serving millions more daily trips, though I hear that they are blowing billions of dollars on some new subway stations to replace existing bus service, oh, kinda like the GLX.
Boston has built ZERO major league baseball parks in 100 years, while other cities have. So what? One subway station is better than that!
You so right! Like how the
You so right! Like how the Red Line overextended itself from Harvard to Alewife!
Big Bird
For a split second after this photo loaded I thought the guy in the yellow puffy coat was someone in a Big Bird costume. I was all, "Wow, things in Boston have really gone downhill."
It's Barney's yellow belly cousin...
Baker DeLeo.