Ryan Benharris has gone through the list of concerts at Fenway Park since they started in 2003, and found that out of all 66 concerts, only one has had a black headliner - and that even then, Jay-Z had to share billing with Justin Timberlake.
Hosting one (or one half) of a concert by a non-white performer over the course of sixteen years on public permits is discrimination of the most blatant kind.
It’s not just on the city. It’s on the Red Sox. It’s on the artists like Zak Brown Band, Bruce Springsteen, Dave Matthews Band, Pearl Jam, Foo Fighters, Phish, and Billy Joel to at least acknowledge that this is happening in Boston.
Entirely white performers at every show at Fenway Park don’t represent the Red Sox and they don’t represent Boston. The citizens of Boston deserve better than this bad look.
Do better @RedSox
Like the job UHub is doing? Consider a contribution. Thanks!
Ad:
Comments
Why Sweet Caroline?
By Waquiot
Fri, 02/01/2019 - 10:23pm
Because it was played once between innings and the fans reacted well to it. The batters come up to all genres of music, but for some reason that Neil Diamond song has stuck. It's odd, but since my favorite soccer club is know for singing a song from the Rogers and Hamerstein musical Carousel, I cannot criticize the taste of sports fan.
That said, perhaps the owners of said soccer club could perhaps experiment on some non-white acts. I mean, since they now have a bunch of concerts each summer, one or two days wouldn't hurt.
It predates Fenway's use as a Boston thing
By tachometer
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:49am
Jim Plunkett (not the quarterback) has been playing around Boston and Cape Cod for years and his fan base definitely leans towards the "townie" type. His shows feature a lot of call and response type stuff that he "trains" the audience in and his version of Sweet Caroline featured the now infamous "so good, so good, so good" by the audience. After they introduced recorded music in addition to the organ at Fenway when it was played it was almost a Pavlovian response in the stands by people who would see him and it ended up catching on with a wider audience through that. I saw Jim Plunkett many times long before recorded music and Sweet Caroline was a thing at Fenway and even introduced the "so good" chant to a bar I worked at in DC when in college which was well before that too.
Here's the originator.
Holy crap grampa
By Smart Arse
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 5:07pm
Damn that guy must be REALLY old.
(and you as well).
The background
By Stevil
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 6:25pm
At least how I recall hearing it from an insider, the young guy in charge of the music was having a baby and got The Call. Threw on Sweet Caroline because they were naming the baby...you guessed it, and made for the hospital. The rest, as they say, is history.
I heard something similar
By tachometer
Sun, 02/03/2019 - 7:11am
That could be the background as to why the song was first played over the PA system at Fenway. It's just that a lot of people think seem to think that the "so good" chant originated at the park but it was definitely a thing around town before that.
So unworld class. Next thing
By anon
Fri, 02/01/2019 - 9:38pm
So unworld class. Next thing you know people will be hurling racial epitaphs at Fenway Park.
Racial Epitaphs
By SwirlyGrrl
Fri, 02/01/2019 - 9:58pm
Trying to think of what that might look like.
Something like "Here Lies An Old White Idiot Buried In His MAGA Hat. Good Riddance."
Or maybe one of those angels in blackface on the tombstone?
Or better yet
By Smart Arse
Fri, 02/01/2019 - 10:29pm
the Governor of Virginia
Or
By Stephen Bickerton Sr
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 9:17am
Whoopie and Black faceTed Danson. Are they still touring?
Snoop dog. Does he still tour with women on leashes?
Bean Counter ! !
By Boston_Bloke
Fri, 02/01/2019 - 11:03pm
The diversity police are on patrol.
Adam can we get your input on
By anon
Fri, 02/01/2019 - 11:53pm
Adam can we get your input on this? It seems to me that you post these articles as click bait.
You need internet traffic on your site, a site that is often informative, and which many of us do appreciate. But sometimes you post articles like these that scream “comment here, to justify my existence to my advertisersâ€.
Fenway host concerts that will sell out. That’s all there is to it.
Your thoughts? Are you about to buy a ticket to a Chief Keef concert? Or is A Tribe Called Quest, a fantastic rap group, reuinting and coming soon to a stadium near me? Cause I would go.
What’s your favorite Tribe song?
Clickbait?
By adamg
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:59am
If what I'm posting offends you, don't click on it. Pretty simple.
Most people seem to follow that advice, because, based on my logs, I'm a complete failure at clickbaitery.
First, the page that gets the most views, by far, on any given day is the home page. I don't post links on social media directly to the home page, so strike one for my alleged clickbait efforts.
Second, the logs also show that over the past 30 days, almost half my visitors are "direct" visitors (46.2% to be exact), meaning they came here through a bookmark or typing in the URL, rather than following one of the links I so deviously spread around Twitter and Facebook (or which my minions so deviously spread around). Another 37% are coming in via search engines, which means they're looking for something specific.
So most people are not being baited by my links. They're repeat visitors (in a given month, about 72% are return visitors) who, for whatever reasons, just want to see what I'm posting. And because I sort of still adhere to blog style, you don't even have to click on a link on the home page to get the main point of most of my posts. If I had to depend on clickbait, I'd have had to declare bankruptcy long ago.
As for concerts at Fenway, I've never been to a single one, even though I'm right in Billy Joel's target demographic. I'm kind of a homebody, up here in the HubCave in our mountain fastness.
So, no, personally, the artist roster at Fenway doesn't affect me one way or or the other. But I am interested in the sort of city we are and are becoming. And in a city that is now minority majority, yes, I am very interested in things like the an analysis of the racial makeup of concerts at one of the city's largest venues, especially when they show that less than 1% of those concerts are by artists who aren't white.
An interesting thing about the clicks
By Waquiot
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 10:59pm
Twice, I've been looking for something, did a google search, and was directed to your page. The first was when I was curious if anyone had done anything on the Canterbury Brook (great work, by the way.) The other was today, when I was looking for a list of Fenway concerts after reading this (nothing, but if someone has a good list, please link.)
compared to what?
By Roger Fink
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 2:46am
It's a lot of work for somebody, but the same analysis for all the 40,000+ seat big-city concert venues would say a lot about to what degree this is a nationwide phenomenon and where Boston fits into it. There are going to be disparities and they would be interesting.
FWIW, I agree with Mr. Benhariss' sentiments.
Boston subconscious Racist
By Jay
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 3:07am
This could very welll be the only large city in the western world where you point out 65 white artist to 1 black artist in a city with a 2:1 white:black ratio...and the white people say you’re ‘reaching’.
Then they wanna complain about ‘the media’ giving the city a bad rep. You’re all doing that on this board-and y’all are the liberal ones.
You all deserve a round of applause for your adamantv enial and obtuseness. Truly inspirational racism, truly.
Black people (and white people) all over the globe know you’re here and it’s probably why they’re not eager to perform in one of Boston’s most famous venues. This is the majority of the audience.
Anyone who’s not disgusted at the count is a racist of some degree and that’s not really debatable.
So the residents of the city
By Lmo
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 12:16pm
So the residents of the city of Boston choose who plays at Fenway now?!? Nah, that’s BS.
Do performers contact Fenway to play concerts at the venue or vice versa? If Fenway is seeking out ppl to perform and not including artists of color, that is a problem, a big problem. But if performers contact Fenway to book the venue, who fault is it that artists of color haven’t played there?
You would need to ask Drake or Bruno Marz...
By Pete Nice
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 12:25pm
Because those two are really the only two big "non white" concert tours going around that didn't play there (except for a few Latin stars). The Jay Z/Beyonce concert was there, and they are in the top 5 concert tours out of anyone.
Everyone else probably isn't going to sell enough tickets. So except for Bruno and Drake, I can't think of anyone you could put in there that might sell out?
Migos, Nicki Minaj?
By Lmo
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 1:09pm
Migos, Nicki Minaj?
Mijos is with Drake and Minaj has bombed....
By Pete Nice
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 2:19pm
So I still can't think of many others except for some top Latin stars, who do well at other Boston venues (Garden and Agganis)
Black owned radio gave up on Boston too
By Boston_Bloke
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 10:27pm
If this is your concern in life then consider yourself privileged. There are people in Venezuela who haven't had a full meal in months but your concern in life is if Mary J Blige adds Fenway to her tour calendar.
Music is a genre not a color. Fenway attracts a certain music genre, mostly classic rock, that has nothing to do with color. R&B acts head to Lynn or Malden. Should we get our undies in a twist that Billy Joel isn't playing at the Lynn Auditorium? It's actually a nice venue and GREAT for seeing a concert. Much more intimate than Fenway. But you're too hung up on bean counting to see that many R&B artists perform at what is clearly an undervalued venue.
Another big issue is demographics. Bean counters focus too much on the color of the population. Boston has a large black population but it is heavily Haitian and Caribbean and not African-American.
That impacts the audiences available for concert tours.
Radio and the music industry are somewhat tied to each other. Media One is the largest black owned media company in the US and even they gave up on Boston. Media One couldn't make an urban contemporary formatted radio successful in Boston. Now iHeartMedia has it on 97.7 R&B, albeit an R&B station with a very bland, corporate tested playlist, that relies on attracting suburbanites who's taste in R&B is limited to pop acts like TLC and En Vogue. This station would fail miserably in Philly or New York competing against real R&B stations like WDAS and WBLS that play real R&B
Bands/Singers for ole white music lovers
By MrsMuir
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 6:51am
In no particular order, I think most of the bands below might sell-out Fenway Park.
When they were alive and fit it the 2003 start-of-concerts @ Fenway Park:
- Aretha Franklin
- Prince
- Michael Jackson
Not touring but, again, fit the 2003 start-of-concerts @ Fenway Park:
- Tina Turner
Many of these still touring:
- Stevie Wonder
- Parliament-Funkadelic
- Bootsy Collins
- Santana
- Buddy Guy
- WAR
- Tower of Power
- George Benson
- Al Green
- Mavis Staples
- Toni Braxton
- Sly + The Family Stone
- Rufus w/Chaka Khan
- Lionel Richie
- Smokie Robinson
- Janet Jackson
- Patti LaBelle
- Pointer Sisters
- Isley Brothers
- Kool + The Gang
- The Ohio Players
- The O'Jays
Some of the above might get a bigger draw if they played as a touring entourage.
Oof
By Hardy Har Har
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:11am
I can't imagine ingesting enough drugs that would allow me to envision Mavis Staples selling out Fenway Park.
Speaking as an Ole White Music Lover
By Irma la Douce
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:13am
Stevie Wonder and Sly & the Family Stone, please.
I love that list!!! Side note
By Lmo
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 3:43pm
I love that list!!! Side note; Tavares and the Sugar Hill Gang have played Florian Hall recently.
Quick. I haven’t been triggered in over an hour
By Roztonian
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 7:42am
Good lord this is beyond rediculous. Bottom line is that if you can find acts (outside of Beyonce) that would command well over $100 just to get in the door then ownership would do it. They target bands like the stones and Pearl Jam because the fans are middle age, in their prime earning period of their careers, and can plop down a few hundred bucks for a two hour show no problem. And the shows will be packed night after night.
Would the writer have the same to say for venues down south that might attract primarily country bands? Racist also I guess. And what about soccer at Fenway? Did they not do a good enough job hosting friendly matches from countries with enough people of color? Get ready, that will be the next criticism
Also, I was at the bruins game the other night. WAY too many white people in the stands and on the ice. Time to ban hockey. Bunch of white guys with sticks. Racist top to bottom
Sorry that you are
By Republican
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 7:58am
Sorry that you are uncomfortable in your own skin Adam aka whitey. You are dividing the nation with your attitude and fake news blog.
Have you considered
By erik g
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 12:54pm
using your trolling powers for good? If you could figure out how to harness the kinetic energy from thousands of people rolling their eyes this hard, we could get the Commonwealth to its emissions goals well before 2050.
Your political party have
By anon
Sun, 02/03/2019 - 3:11am
Your political party have already done far more dividing than anyone can ever hope to outdo
Wow. Someone actually had
By Carmella
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 8:26am
Wow. Someone actually had time to research this. This is a man in dire need of a hobby. What a reach.
Always a hockey game at Fenway too....
By Pete Nice
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 9:41am
Never a basketball game.
Unbelievable and I think this guy is onto something.
Basketball game outside and
By anon
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 10:55am
Basketball game outside and in a baseball park? Can you please give examples of a black city or any city that has ever done that?
Right?
By Hardy Har Har
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:20am
The NBA does not have a history of playing outdoor games. By the time you'd have a reasonable assurance of decent weather, you'd be in the playoffs or off-season.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NBA_outdoor_games
Are
By anon
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:21am
You saying the NBA has a diversity issue. Also, please name a single NBA event which takes place outdoors. You think drama queens like Lebron want to play outdoors in the cold?
Oh so basketball players aren't as tough as hockey players?
By Pete Nice
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:44am
Shame on you.
What for being honest
By anon
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 12:11pm
Sometimes the truth hurts. The NBA has more flops than European football.
Ive seen tougher kids playing dodge ball in grade school
By anon
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 12:14pm
https://video.search.yahoo.com/search/video?fr=mca...
WaaaaaH .. is that all there is to worry about ????
By tedpk
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 10:53am
I don't doubt that the person who triggered the story was sincerely interested in the issue -- and then perhaps after seeing the result became concerned.
BUT this is not a headline of importance --- and it has Nothing to do with Racism. John Henry and the Red Sox ownership & C-level of FSG, LLC*1 --- are probably some of the most liberal [some would say Lefty] major ownership in Sports. After all John Henry's owns the Boston Globe -- hardly a bastion of Trumpism.
Here's a quote from a Forbes story about FSG, LLC*1 aka the Red Sox + Fenway, etc. = John Henry & Friends
*2
What is more interesting than the story as someone has pointed out -- is the Knee Jerk responses to the story.
Ultimately, its all about Business and Math -- once again STEAMB [Science, Technology, Engineering, Art, Math, Business] is shown to be valuable compared to Ignorance, Fear, Hatred and the usual suspects.
Let's put it in perspective:
Neither Fenway Park -- the mothership of Fenway Sports Group*1 -- nor the Res Sox could survive on just the population of the City of Boston -- no matter what its racial or ethnic makeup -- its just not big enough. Look at the size of the city proper behind the rich teams [e.g. Houston --2.3 Million, NYC --8.1 Million, LA -- 4 Million, Chicago --2.7 Million ] all are far bigger in population than within Boston's city limits
What makes Fenway and the Red Sox aka Fenway Sports Group, LLC successful as a business venture*2 is that they have figured out how to capitalize on the New England Effect -- and use it as a base to become a Global Enterprise*2,3
It all about Scaling [to the nearest 10,000 from wikipedia] and your audience:
Boston proper has about 700,000 people = 1 Congressional District size
Throw in the rest of Suffolk County and the contiguous suburbs:
Cambridge -- 110,000
Newton -- 90,000
Quincy-- 90,000
Sommerville -- 80,000
Brookline -- 60,000
Revere -- 50,000
Chelsea -- 40,000
Watertown -- 40,000
Milton -- 30,000
Dedham --30,000
Winthrop -- 20,000
subtotal = 640,000 [almost the size of Boston]
Total = 1,340,000 [approx 2 Cong Districts]
The rest of the inner suburbs within or touching Rt. 128 add about another 1,000,000
and now the total you gets comfortably past 2 Million and approaching 2.5 Million -- Houston City Size
keep going out to the Boundaries of the T and you are well past 3 Million
The direct signals of the Big 4 TV Stations reach over 4.5 Million including Worcester, Manchester NH
Greater Boston MSA*4 == 4,730,000 -- about the size of the City of LA
Greater Boston CSMA*4 == 8,100,000 -- about the size of NYC
Go all the way out to encompass New England -- 14,100,000 -- a couple of Millions bigger than Pennsylvania and a couple of Millions short of NY State
Throw in the Canadian Maritimes if you want -- overall the core of Red Sox Nation might approach 20 Million -- NESN cable coverage
That's who FSG markets the Red Sox and through them Fenway as a venue for Hockey, Ice Racing and Concerts -- and Yes it is an overwhelmingly Euro-based population
No surprise and no guilt either -- that's just what it is
Now let everybody go back to doing something hopefully productive!
*1 Fenway Sports Group from the Wikipedia Article:
*2
*3 Considered by many to be one of the top Sports-related businesses
*4 Greater Boston from Wiki
and
Franklin Park
By anon
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 11:50am
There should not be any concerts at Fenway Park. Have concerts at Franklin Park or White Stadium.
they do:
By schneidz
Sun, 02/03/2019 - 12:29am
they do:
soca in the park / reggae in the park.
What would Elvis say ?
By anon
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 3:12pm
What would Elvis say ?
On Black People
By Kapil
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 6:43pm
Black people do not like Fenway. They have little reverence for the park itself somewhat because of the Yawkey stuff but mainly because baseball is not that popular with them. They prefer not to be outside during concerts exposed to the elements. With white people, it gets complicated. They are interested in venues with "character" and get more excited to see their favorite musical groups play in these venues so they can post about it. Black people could care less about that and only want a venue that's new, comfortable, and with better amenities, such as TD Garden.
Is Henry haunted by lack of blacks on stage or in front office?
By O-FISH-L
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 7:33pm
John Henry infamously said he was "haunted" by philanthropist Tom Yawkey's racism, yet in 2018, the Red Sox still weren't able to count how people of color worked in the front office? Please. This isn't Walmart or China Petroleum with millions of employees. Far-left WBUR dutifully left it alone, not asking when the "data will be readily available." BTW, how many African-Americans in the front office of the Globe?
Publicity hounds, Red Sox owners follow the news closely and most likely are frightened by stories like this one on UHub about a City Hall Plaza rap concert that ended in violence . They apparently don't want that element on stage or in the front office but it's OK, John Henry is a devout liberal and opposes Trump. Kudos to Ryan Benharris for exposing these frauds.
I hate having to quote my own stuff...
By tedpk
Sat, 02/02/2019 - 9:50pm
Sometimes the Knees Jerk so violently that --- almost nothing makes it from the eyes to the brain
Under those kinds of conditions -- the Knee Jerker is unlikely to read more than one or two lines before they fire off a preconceived or pre-prepared by someone else's talking points
Well anyway here's the quote from my longish post -- followed with a brief explanation
What that means is that one component of Fenway Sports Group is the Fenway Sports Management --- and at least at the time one of their Clients was LeBron James
It was LeBron who recruited Jay Z to play a concert at Fenway Sounds like a max-ed out White Supremacist plot doesn't it!!
OK -- Comprenez vous, Verstehen Sie, Rozumiesz, Enteneu, du forstår, Érted?????????
Before you bring up that City Hall rap concert again ...
By adamg
Sun, 02/03/2019 - 10:55am
You might want to take a look at the artist in question, and consider what race his fans might have been. You're also old enough to remember the Green Day riot on the Esplanade, which involved artists every bit as pale as you or I.
Wow, I can't believe how
By cden4
Mon, 02/04/2019 - 9:57am
Wow, I can't believe how triggered people are by this question. Knowing how racist Boston is, you'd think people would maybe think twice before they instinctively respond "no we're not!"
A few theories about the Fenway concerts:
- Management is trying to appeal to the largest demographic who currently attends and spends money at Red Sox games: middle aged to older white people.
- Management is worried about the "wrong element" coming to Fenway and causing problems either in the venue or outside the venue before or after. I'm sure they are afraid of the bad press if there is a shooting or some other incident.
Are both of these reasons racist? Yup. The first one is slightly more excusable than the second, but not by much.
Lets keep it that way ! Just
By Archie
Thu, 02/14/2019 - 4:25pm
Lets keep it that way ! Just sayin
Pages
Add comment