Hey, there! Log in / Register

Former state GOP head declares he is not a racist or a bigot, sues Baker-aligned Republicans he claims falsely said he is

Former Massachusetts GOP Chairman Jim Lyons today sued several people who supported his arch-nemesis, Charlie Baker, for defamation for what he says was a multi-year campaign to paint him as a racist who particularly hated Asian-Americans.

Lyons called that absurd and harmful in his complaint, filed in Suffolk Superior Court against Jim Conroy, Brian Wynne, Matthew Sisk, Mark Steffen, Sean Powers and Ben Maroon.

Conroy helped run Baker's 2014 election campaign and his 2018 re-election campaign. Wynne worked on Baker's 2018 campaign as well. Powers served as Baker's driver in his unsuccessful 2010 campaign and oversaw his 2015 inauguration festivities. Sisk was a pro-Baker member of the Republican State Committee after Lyons took over - and was one of two committee members that Lyons paid a detective to investigate, along with Maura Healey's sex life. Steffen, whose name the complaint misspells, ran Anthony Amore's unsuccessful campaign for state auditor last year.

The complaint also mentions, but not as a defendant, one-time perennial Boston candidate Doug Bennett, now an attorney, who has done work for Republicans in New Hampshire and Massachusetts. But that could be because Lyons sued Bennett for defamation separately in Essex Superior Court in 2021. That case has yet to come to trial; just last month, Bennett moved to try to quash depositions Lyons is seeking for a number of his Republican enemies, including several he sued today.

Also unnamed: Ron Kaufman, longtime member of the Republican National Committee from Massachusetts, who a year ago Lyons called the ringleader of the effort against him.

In today's complaint, Lyons charged that Wynne, a political consultant, organized a company called Red Massachusetts Grassroots LLC, three months after Lyons, a newly defeated state rep, won election as party chairman in 2019, with the goal of defaming him.

According to its incorporation papers with the Secretary of State's office, the company stated a goal "to provide strategic political consulting and campaign management services." However, the state Office of Campaign and Political Finance shows no payments from campaigns to the company from the time it was formed to the time it filed for dissolution on July 11, 2022. In the fall elections that year, enough non-Lyons backers won election to the state committee to force out Lyons, a Ted-Cruz-turned-Donald-Trump supporter.

The complaint alleges the campaign of what Lyons calls "the Team" who ran Red Massachusetts and with legal counsel from Bennett, reached a climax in April, 2021, when, he alleges, his haters convinced the Globe to run a story headlined "Asian American Republicans accuse state GOP of pursuing discriminatory scheme to disenfranchise them in party elections." Or as the complaint puts it:

On or about April 19, 2021, The Team implemented a plan to defame the plaintiff by publicizing a false narrative that the plaintiff was a racist, a bigot and anti-Asian, all in an effort to destroy Mr. Lyon's reputation. ... On or about April 26, 2021, this false narrative was released to the Boston Globe to be distributed to the public.

The story referenced complaints by two dozen Asian-American Republicans across the state and referenced the way Lyons disbanded ward committees in a Boston district that runs from Fields Corner, which has a large Vietnamese-American community, into South Boston.

In his complaint, Lyons says he had little choice to dissolve the Ward 15 committee because:

[I]t was discovered that the residences of individuals listed in the ward formation forms failed to match the addresses that were listed in the sworn documents that were submitted to the Office of [sic] Campaign and Political Finance. Upon review it was discovered that the mailings had a return address under the name of the defendant Mark Steffen.

Also that year, the Republican State Committee under Lyons spent roughly $3,700 to support Boston City Council candidate Donnie Palmer, who accused then mayoral candidate Michelle Wu of being a stooge of virus-spreading Chinese communists who wanted to colonize the city - and said that she and US Rep. Ayanna Pressley were Chicago "gangsters." Palmer came in 14th out of 17 candidates for four open seats in the preliminary election.

Lyons is seeking a jury trial at which to prove he's been defamed, for which he is demanding a court order making his enemies retract all the bad things they said about him, plus damages, costs and interest.

As a result of the defamation by the defendants, the plaintiff has been harmed financially and personally and has been held in low esteem by the public who heard or read the defamatory statements orchestrated by the defendants.

Topics: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon Complete complaint400.02 KB


Ad:


Like the job UHub is doing? Consider a contribution. Thanks!

Comments

namely, forcing Democrats in the state legislature to assemble a quorum to pass needed legislation, the clowns come back on stage.

up
Voting closed 3

What’s so useful about a quorum? It was only useful in this instance because Republicans refused to let the needed bill pass otherwise - using their leverage to maximum capacity to … slow down enactment of a spending bill by a few days. Great job, guys!

*Just because Democratic lawmakers shouldn’t have gotten to the point where a bunch of attention-starved Republicans could jam up needed legislation doesn’t mean you should celebrate Republicans for jamming them up.

up
Voting closed 0

They managed to get enough people back to fund a supplemental budget for things like, oh, already inked collective bargaining agreements and other important things left out of the main budget.

up
Voting closed 0

Anything (within reason, that doesn't hurt people of course) that draws attention to the opaque, dysfunctional, corrupt way that the speaker-for-life Ron Mariano and president-for-life Karen Spilka dominated state legislature does business is good, IMO.

up
Voting closed 0

He’s been Speaker since 2020.

Maybe you make a very precocious 3-year-old.

up
Voting closed 3

Let me answer as a 3-year-old, "no duh".

The point is, because Ron Mariano exercises absolute power over the members of the house and his position has no term limits, there is no meaningful way to remove him other than by federal indictment. (Luckily, this happens fairly regularly in this state, I guess that sweet absolute power is easy to illegally abuse)

Because your childish insult tells me you're missing the point, here's further detail: https://prospect.org/politics/2023-12-04-massachusetts-blues-progressive...

But hold on, didn’t voters just elect reformers to the top posts? Not quite. The most powerful politician on Beacon Hill remains a 77-year-old state representative named Ron Mariano, who was elected by exactly 10,085 voters in Norfolk County. He’s the Speaker of the state House of Representatives. And the Massachusetts legislature has procedures to ensure total leadership control that would make Boss Tweed blush.

The leadership and lobbyists make deals behind closed doors. There are no recorded votes in House committees, where legislation is often sent to die, making it impossible to hold representatives accountable. Full texts of bills are often unavailable, and final passage on the floor is usually by voice vote. Technically, a member can demand a roll call, and it does happen once in a while. But to do it is to court retribution.

Outing a fellow member to “take a difficult vote” even has a uniquely Beacon Hill term of opprobrium. It’s called “spotting,” and is considered an unfriendly act. “You are not supposed to make anybody uncomfortable. It’s a culture of comfort that often trumps the interests of the working people who we represent and serve,” says state Sen. Jamie Eldridge, who chairs the Judiciary Committee, and is a rare effective progressive.

To further entrench boss rule, the Speaker can augment the $73,654 base pay of state reps, by sums ranging from $7,095.60 to $88,694.99. He can do this for more than half of the 160 members of the House, by naming them committee chairs, vice chairs, and other honorary leadership positions.

To cross the Speaker is to have your extra pay and staff taken away, and your office abruptly moved to the basement. A few members do choose to play the role of outsider, but they rarely accomplish anything. “If you want that earmark for a senior center in your district,” says Diana DiZoglio, a former renegade legislator who is now state auditor, “you had better not challenge the leadership.”

up
Voting closed 5

Keep churning, you imbecile.

up
Voting closed 2

The level of childish spite in your comments just seems completely unmotivated... unless we've stumbled across Ron Mariano's alt? Or one of his toadies?

up
Voting closed 3

who just has to have the last word.

up
Voting closed 2

Were you looking in the mirror when you posted that?

up
Voting closed 3

All Pete has posted here is a single article that supports the argument he's making, which seems pretty reasonable to me. How about addressing the actual substance of that argument?

up
Voting closed 2

is very difficult to prove, the legal bar being even higher for "public figures," which I would hazard Mr. Lyons seems himself.

up
Voting closed 3

This is a great write-up, and Adam really milked this lawsuit for all it’s worth. After reading all six pages of the complaint, I’m still not sure what the actually false thing said was, who said it. It looks like the lawyer who filed this thing didn’t bother trying to find out… It’s an embarrassing document. Mostly boilerplate and no attempt to explain whether anything defamatory occurred.

up
Voting closed 15

... has entered the courtroom.

up
Voting closed 1

You can't find a false thing said because he actually has said bigoted and racist things and has acted in bigoted and racist ways. Defamation is very hard to prove and pretty much impossible if you actually did/say the things that you claim are defamatory. "Just because I said racist things doesn't mean you should have pointed out that it was racist and now I can't get a job" is not likely going to persuade a judge. And asking for a jury trial ignores the fact that a judge can always call a mistrial if the jury clearly didn't follow law or evidence.

up
Voting closed 3

He may be trying to squeak through on the claim that he said nasty things about lots of non-white-people, but didn't come out and say that all Asian-Americans are dishonest.

That won't win his case--he would have to show not only that the statements he's objecting to are false, but that the people who said them knew or should have known that, and then show that they harmed his reputation. But it's a line of reasoning that might convince a lawyer to take the case.

Also, if this guy said X or Y in public, it's not slander to report that fact. Even if it's something that he wishes he hadn't said, or if mentioning it would make people think badly of him.

up
Voting closed 1

Even without a law degree, you can tell he is just mad, and taking cues from our nation's most prominent frivolous litigant.

up
Voting closed 3

I miss shredding ole Dougie Bennett in here. Worst part is Tompkins turned out to be just as bad if not worse!

up
Voting closed 4

is a Boomer fathead who would appoint Howie Carr Governor if he could and has the intellectual acumen of a traffic cone. The sooner he fades away the better, whoever replaces him can’t be stupider or much more malignant.

But again, you never know with the Mass GOP. Pushing more crap than Casella.

up
Voting closed 2

Lyons and Carr hate one another with the intensity of a thousand suns. Just check today's Herald for proof.

up
Voting closed 2

It's one thing to have newspaper articles reporting all the, some would say, vile things an Ultra-MAGA RINO like Jim J. Lyons Jr. has said and done; It's quite another thing to have those things laid out and verified in court documents. Unfortunately for him; Former Representative James J. Lyons Jr. has chosen the wrong hill to die on.

The results of him going through with this case and what this case reveals is what historians will remember him for regardless of what he may have done earlier in his tenure.

up
Voting closed 2